I mean listen, you have very reputable individuals who believe in validation, as experimental proof. Check my single page unpublishable http://dftuz.unizar.es/~rivero/research/simple.pdf. With Alejandro Jodorowsky, Horacio Salinas, Zamira Saunders, Juan Ferrara. It comes from the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, and it's about the limitations of trying to measure the position and momentum of subatomic particles. As the sample size grows, so does the scientist's confidence in the statistical inferences drawn from the large sample. I guess it's a sign that quantum physics is entering the mainstream A: Well, yeah, the point is that there have been these new-age desires for lots of things to make the world better: crystals, energy vortices. Neither of them convincingly achieve this. There were many more, but I will leave them for others. This is the first coronavirus vaccine approved by the FDA, and is expected to open the door to more vaccine mandates. During the resulting chat, two men carrying a wooden door passed between the stranger and the subjects. One should take seriously the danger that hes not the only one deluding himself. subscription. John Hagelin, PhD, describes a study he did in Washington in 1992. A: Quantum mechanics is often quoted as the explanation for many things, because it's so weird that people latch onto it as a hope, to explain everything that they would like to believe about the universe. As the layers to her everyday experiences fall away insertions in the story with scientists, and philosophers and religious leaders . IE 11 is not supported. [6], The Institute of Noetic Sciences, a New Age research organization that "explores phenomena that do not necessarily fit conventional scientific models", has supported What the Bleep Do We Know!? One possible answer: they go to an alternative universe where people are asking the same question: 'where'd they go?'" to someone you know: Everyone said that you have to see this movie! So I did. On August 1, 2006 What the Bleep! Pingback: yeago works Blog Archive Jesus, Buddha, Ken Wilber?? Having watched this travesty of a movie, any real scientist worth his quarks might be gun-shy about joining the debate. Real news, real hope. Blending New Age mysticism and quantum physics, What The Bleep Do We Know?! "The theory can't predict with precision what will happen, but it knows everything that can happen and it will tell you the probability of all these things happening.". (Physicists should take part of the blame for this confusion. If I didnt know any better, I would have thought it was something straight out of a Cheech and Chong movie. [13] The American Chemical Society's review criticizes the film as a "pseudoscientific docudrama", saying "Among the more outlandish assertions are that people can travel backward in time, and that matter is actually thought. One of the scientists who was in the film and had never appeared at the school is Dr David Albert Professor and Director of Philosophical Physics at Columbia university. To date, there has been no response as to where the information which lead to the story about the indians not being able to see the ships of Columbus originated from. In the documentary segments of the film, interviewees discuss the roots and meaning of Amanda's experiences. Certainly, our attitudes and brain chemistry affect how we see the world and get through life. - Dr. We might be able to create quantum computers, for example, that will simultaneously do many different calculations at once, because the quantum world is capable of doing many things at the same time. A disproportionate amount of time was given in voice and film to Ramtha, Dr. Joe dispenza, and Miceal Ledwith. The Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle argues that its impossible to track the momentum and position of a subatomic particle. But it's not true for the universe at large. [1], The films co-director, Mark Vicente, would go on to co-found The Knife Media, a pro-Trump digital news outlet linked to NXIVM. Many religions and spiritual paths--from Hinduism, with its concept of maya, to Christian Science--teach that appearance is illusion. 19802023 The Christian Science Monitor. Right now they use a key that's based on the products of large prime numbers, and no computer could determine the prime factors in a time shorter than the age of the universe. Also, the movie suggests that the quantum idea of matter embracing all its possible states at once applies to the larger world of people and rocks. Quantum mechanics is a replacement for the phrase "anything goes." That's not always true, but it's often true. 2004 ( ) ( ) Offline 2013. The director, William Arntz, has described What the Bleep as a film for the "metaphysical left". [12][13] Lisa Randall refers to the film as "the bane of scientists". does a reasonable job of presenting some of these quandaries, researchers say. He claims the drop was achieved. Next factoid: Crime in Washington, D.C. was reduced 25 percent by prayer--and made believers of the D.C. cops! By 1984 he had moved to Maharishi University and started building up the physics department there. (It's all to do with photons of light from your measuring instrument hitting the poor electron and knocking it for six). A classic experiment on visual processing involves asking people to watch a video of 6 people passing a basketball, and press a button every time a particular team has possession. No, that wasnt intended specifically as an attack on supersymmetric models; the fact that Hagelin worked on them isnt an argument for or against them. Who believe, in all kinds of things(God maybe?). What was new? They don't go anywhere, Fred. Particles Popping Into & Out of Existence. She's averse to churches (she married her husband in one, so they must be bad! 2) "What the Bleep Do We Know" has sure got a lot of people talking and thinking. ?, with over 15 hours of material on three double-sided DVDs. "I create my own reality, says quantum physics," intones one expert, and the viewer could be lured to accept this as proof. was heavily criticised for being "a documentary aimed at the totally gullible". While the (probabilistic) predictions of quantum mechanics are, as far . (commonly referred to by its spoken title What the Bleep Do We Know) is a 2004 pseudoscientific film that supports the idea that consciousness and quantum mechanics are somehow related. You can't change the world by thinking about it. Intercut with these metaphysical ponderings is a soapy fictional narrative starring Marlee Matlin as a broken-hearted photographer. Fred Allen Wolf It's actually the machine that's the observer, not the human who's jotting down results. His list of "worst abusers" includes inspirational author Deepak Chopra, the best-selling book "The Secret" and the whole field of Transcendental Meditation. Andrew B Newberg, (MD, Radiologist), in What the Bleep Do We Know? It is my task to convince you not to turn away because you don't understand it. But we're certainly using them at the Large Hadron Collider, which we couldn't even operate if we didn't have superconducting magnets. Present thinking on neurology and addiction are covered in some detail but,. Matt, what is so nutty about Serge Langs ideas about HIV and AIDS? ?, never before seen DVD programming features, 20 minutes of new animation, new interviews, along with 5 hours of uncut interviews and a filmmakers Q&A, the Quantum Edition contains over 15 hours of material on 6 DVD sides. It's truly amazing that you can separate two elementary particles that were originally tied together, and often make a measurement of one particle that instantly affects the other, even if it's on Alpha Centauri. So what better thing to have than something that gives you everything you want? They may applaud the central tenets of the movie, but not its disjointed narrative, clunky acting, bizarre thematic segues, and faux "facts." For traditional Christians, God is God not because your brain is making him up, but because he is. improve functionality and performance. Get ABC Sciences weekly newsletter Science Updates, The 'underground astronaut' in search of ancient bones, Voyager probes still signalling from the edge of the Solar System, Solar eclipses: Everything you need to know, Five ways your smartphone could help save lives, Chinese scientists use satellite to smash quantum entanglement record, Einstein's light bending theory directly observed in distant stars for first time, Third gravitational wave detection puts new spin on black holes. If he says hes being misrepresented, I quite believe him. He announced in 1994 (one year after the study) that violent crime had decreased 18%. What the Bleep Do We Know!? If you wanted to study the impact of spoken, drawn or written sentiments on the formation of crystals in freezing water, you'd have to do a slightly more rigorous study. the film What The Bleep Do We Know It was an information that really left me speechless and I ordered his books at once techhose.d-webhost.orphans.co.uk 2 / 11. So on one hand you have a threat to security, and on the other you have a possible boon for security. You are free to comment as you wish. unless you renew or We do, at subatomic scale, behave quantum mechanically. What the Bleep Do We Know was directed and produced by Betsy Chasse, Mark Vicente and William Arntz, all of whom were students of Ramtha's School of Enlightenment. What could be worse than being aware of every tiny detail that your brain handles from phosphate levels to heart rate and hair growth. Join the Cosmic Log corps by signing up as my Facebook friend or hooking up on Twitter. By clicking 'Send to a friend' you agree ABC Online is not responsible for the content contained in your email message. The movie gives two examples of experiments which have shown the power of the mind affecting reality. Wow, indeed! According to Joo Magueijo, professor in theoretical physics at Imperial College, the film deliberately misquotes science. Q: Some scientists, such as Sir Roger Penrose, have talked about neurons as quantum systems. Extreme quantum mechanics could be the name of the speciality of SF writer (and physicist) Greg Egan. DO WE KNOW? The meditation may not have helped the victims of violent crime, but it did win Hagelin the 1994 Ig Nobel Peace Prize. The main thing to know is that "observation" is a bad word for the process which goes on which we have inherited from the days when quantum mechanics was first discovered, and is unfortunately a bit easier to teach in introductory courses than decoherence. And you'd do the study without knowing what had been 'said' to the water specimens, so your subjective opinions wouldn't colour the results. And a lot of people talk about quantum consciousness that even if the everyday world we see is not a system that can be changed, our consciousness about the world can be changed. If anyone has any information to refute any of the facts laid out here, I will be more then willing to retract them. It's recognized as pedagogical exaggeration. After a successful DVD launch in March of 2005, Fox . My FIL is a ex-Air force Pilot. Featuring interviews with scientists and theologians, this compelling film thrusts the viewer into a world where science and spirituality intersect. has been described as "a kind of New Age answer to The Passion of the Christ and other films that adhere to traditional religious teachings. "Physical reality is absolutely rock solid, yet it only comes into existence when it bumps up against another piece of physical reality like us, or a rock." is released on Friday. We may be able to use quantum communication in ways that we haven't done before. However, it contends that the empty space is not that empty, it is only the human mind that is unable to see beyond the emptiness. A lot of the propaganda from them was hilarious, especially whenever candidates attempted to hold public speeches and performing demonstrations of yogic flying. I remember Hagelin wanting to discuss how quantum field theory could explain how TMers were able to levitate, something about how they did this by changing the position of the pole in the propagator. We're also connected to the universe by gravity, and we're connected to the planets by gravity. Human everyday life consists of many routines and necessary things that are mostly physical such as work, school, a number of chores or minor responsibilities, and hopefully sleep. Those points suggest that quantum-derived "possibilities" affect the wider world, that human thought is the ultimate arbiter of physical reality, and that by manipulating thought properly, people can achieve harmony and even shape the structure of matter. Gifted and talented kids: how do you nurture a curious mind. The movie contains interviews from such leaders in their fields as: Candace. [3], Work was split between Toronto-based Mr. X Inc., Lost Boys Studios in Vancouver, and Atomic Visual Effects in Cape Town, South Africa. This website uses cookies to Everything from the possibility of disappearing and reappearing, to the possibility of having strange new forms of communication. The movie "What the Bleep do we know" How much is true, or just entertainment. Filmed to promote a new age philosophy based on a very, very broad interpretation of quantum physics, the movie was funded by J. Here's an edited transcript: Cosmic Log: Every once in a while, you'll hear about something like "The Secret," or some other reference to quantum mechanics as explaining how you can change your universe, or even perhaps why it's in the realm of possibility that a globe-gobbling black hole could be created because "anything can happen" in quantum mechanics. Therefore people get the notion that there's no objective reality, and that you can literally impact on the external world just by doing things internally. The quantum world does pervade everything around us, but as Richard Feynman liked to say, "Scientific creativity is imagination in a straitjacket." It was the biggest bunch of garbage that I had ever seen. With Marlee Matlin, Elaine Hendrix, John Ross Bowie, Robert Bailey Jr.. A fictional photographer's quest to spiritually rediscover herself is interspersed with documentary footage of scientists and theologians discussing the philosophical aspects of quantum physics. ?, with over 15 hours of material on three double-sided DVDs. The quantum mechanical correlations, the spooky action at a distance that quantum mechanics brings up, is true only for very specially prepared systems that are isolated from the rest of the world, completely. Even followers of spiritual traditions that believe in worldly illusion will have problems with "Bleep." What the Bleep Do We Know was directed and produced by Betsy Chasse, Mark Vicente and William Arntz, all of whom were students of Ramthas School of Enlightenment. Do We (K)now!? Reality is happening in our brain all the time we're receiving it but it's not being integrated." Update: More information at the end of the video description.Comment approval now removed. 3. Easton's 1897 Bible Dictionary. In one experiment, people who were walking across a college campus were asked by a stranger for directions. Producing, scripting, and co-directing the film, What the BLEEP went on to become a global phenomenon, with well over 100 million viewers experiencing the BLEEP. Amanda is a divorced woman who makes a living as a photographer. That's what makes the world so interesting. Initially, the film was released in only two theaters: one in Yelm, Washington (the home of the producers, which is also the home of Ramtha), and the other the Bagdad Theater in Portland, Oregon, where it was filmed. On certain scales, for certain times, in certain regions, everything goes and strange things happen. He is also the theologian in residence of RSE. is a book of amazing science, and now the international bestselling book is available in paperback. What the Bleep Do We Know!? But is reality really in the eye of the quantum observer? "[10], What the Bleep Do We Know!? Both are indeed mysterious, and their genuine mystery needs none of the hype with which this film relentlessly and noisily belabours us", concluding that the film is "tosh". The flip side of that is that you can use quantum mechanics, again in specially prepared systems, to communicate in a way that will allow us to know when someone is eavesdropping. Lawrence Krauss: I think it's probably one of the most abused concepts in physics among the public. Science and engineering are important for our future, and anything that engages the public can only be a good thing." Even so it notched up $10m in. Do We Know!?) Staff meetings are tedious enough give me a conscious mind with a decent filter device any day. They are relevant because of the deliberateness on the part of the film makers to keep certain facts unknown (ironically, it is I making the unknown know) and misrepresent others. Our work isn't possible without your support. It was clearly time to check the facts for myself. He also has been marketing several products within the school and its followers. Around 650 million people watched the moment on television. The film surpassed all expectations; it was certainly the stupidest thing I can remember seeing in a movie theater, and thats saying quite a lot (I see a lot of movies). It demands a freedom of view and greatness of thought so far unknown, indeed, not even dreamed of since Copernicus. The year's most unexpected indie hit in American cinemas - a film about quantum physics - is about to open here. He also invested over $10,000.00 in an infamous scam that infected RSE and was touted by Ramtha as a vehicle to gain fabulous wealth and many of the schools membership lost substantial sums of money. But I assume that's not quite right, and that sometimes quantum mechanics' name is taken in vain. And it certainly doesn't depend on an observer to make this happen. [19], According to Margaret Wertheim, "History abounds with religious enthusiasts who have read spiritual portent into the arrangement of the planets, the vacuum of space, electromagnetic waves and the big bang. A disproportionate amount of time was given in voice and film to Ramtha, Dr. Joe dispenza, and Miceal Ledwith. We ISHEAGU MASSACRE HISTORICAL BACKGROUND: Isheagu is a town whose origin is traceable to the Eastern part of the contraption called Nigeria. I'm always up for a good New Age flick, even one masquerading as a documentary. Has this experiment been replicated or verified? Right after the Velvet Revolution in 1989 (the collapse of the Czechoslovak communism), many new spiritual and other directions were trying to find their ways to the new free countries. The Effect of Meditation on Violent Crime in Washington, DC. Dr Emoto takes photos of crystals formed in freezing water. Filmed in Portland, Oregon, What the Bleep Do We Know!? The part where the scientist put water under a microscope that was sitting under the label "I hate you" or "I want to kill you" Looked distorted and dirty but water blessed by monks was uniform and beautiful. mixed truisms with conjecture, interviews and dramatic "recreations" of the ideas being discussed, to form a kind of cohesive supposition on the link between mind and matter, biology and the Big Bang. Dr. Jeffrey Satinover (psychiatrist, PhD candidate in physics), in What the Bleep Do We Know? Do we know" . [17] Eric Scerri in a review for Committee for Skeptical Inquiry dismisses it as "a hodgepodge of all kinds of crackpot nonsense," where "science [is] distorted and sensationalized". I don't know how many times I've heard people say, "Oh, I love quantum mechanics because I'm really into meditation, or I love the spiritual benefits that it brings me." (2005)", "Cult Science Dressing Up Mysticism as Quantum Physics", "The New Age Spiritualist and the Old School Scholars", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=What_the_Bleep_Do_We_Know!%3F&oldid=1139210194, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, That the universe is best seen as constructed from thoughts and ideas rather than from. Thus, if a scientist repeats an experiment with subatomic particles often enough, the results will closely match the probabilities quantum theory predicts. The observer can't be ignored." Q: But isn't everything really connected? Filename F:\torrent\What the Bleep Do We Know_2CD\disc one\09 What the Bleep.wav Peak level 100.0 % Extraction speed 8.6 X Track quality 100.0 % Test CRC 2A67087E Copy CRC 2A67087E Accurately ripped (confidence 4) [55AC2A89] (AR v1) Copy OK Track 10 Filename F:\torrent\What the Bleep Do We Know_2CD\disc one\10 Circle the Sun.wav Peak level 100.0 % With Marlee Matlin, Elaine Hendrix, Barry Newman, Armin Shimerman. It presents itself as the thinking rebel's alternative to Hollywood pabulum: a heady stew of drama and documentary, starring Oscar-winning actress Marlee Matlin as a Xanax-addled photographer who. Answer (1 of 6): Although not being as well educated in the area as Professor Wacker, I think it's overly simplistic to suggest the subjects raised in the movie to be either factual or "almost completely mumbo-jumbo". Invariably only about half the people tested ever notice a woman in a gorilla suit walking across the middle of the screen during the game. The only problem with Andrew Newberg's statement is that it suggests our subconscious brains are doing really interesting stuff and we're somehow missing out; if only we could harness that other zillion gigabits or so we'd be masters of our destinies. Bleep was conceived and its production funded by William Arntz, who co-directed the film along with Betsy Chasse and Mark Vicente; all three were students of Ramtha's School of Enlightenment. Mark was born in Johannesburg, South Africa . Some lost their entire life savings. That would be, very hard to quantify:). DVD (2005) Marlee Matlin, Arntz (DIR) cert 12 at the best online prices at eBay! [16], David Albert, a philosopher of physics who appears in the film, has accused the filmmakers of selectively editing his interview to make it appear that he endorses the film's thesis that quantum mechanics is linked with consciousness. Heisenberg basically says you can't get a really accurate fix on both the position and the momentum of a subatomic particle say an electron at the same time. "What The Bleep Do We Know? This is one reason physicists studying a subatomic particle create large numbers of them in particle accelerators. But the movie gradually moves to quantum 'insights' that lead a woman to toss away her antidepressant medication, to the quantum channeling of Ramtha, the 35,000-year-old Lemurian warrior, and on to even greater nonsense." What the Bleep Do We Know!? If you have questions about your account, please What the Bleep Do We Know draws heavily on the role of the observer in quantum physics. Quantum mechanics may play a role at some level in the way the brain works just as it may play a role in photosynthesis. But they add that the film shows quantum mysteries selectively to shore up metaphysical points. is god-awful. And quantum mechanics is often used as the explanation for that. And I came out of wanting to meditate more often, which can't be a bad thing. For starters you'd have to take a lot of samples from different parts of each ice specimen. This message will appear once per week Hagelin might be crazy, but some of those papers are co-written by John Ellis and other respectable people. There was some sort of plot involving a woman photographer (played by Marlee Matlin), who wanders around and has anxiety attacks. 7. But quantum mechanics, for better or worse, doesn't bring any more spiritual benefits than gravity does. While Amanda waits for a commuter train, she (and we) are shown the work of Japanese scientist Masaru Emoto, who has photographed water after exposing it to different emotions. We're always being told we don't use our brain to its full capacity. !" is a radical departure from convention. From my perspective, once you had identtified Smolins position( I gave this in previous post[Posted by sol at September 25, 2004 04:18 PM] ), then you would know he holds Einsteins, in relation to the Solvay meetings, and strings have modified what Bohr and Schrodinger were doing in developing QM. To date, Dr Emoto has not taken up the challenge. Doesn't the quantum world pervade everything that we see around us? Hobbs also discusses Hagelin's experiment with Transcendental Meditation and the Washington DC rate of violent crime, saying that "the number of murders actually went up". Then we segue to a narrative starring Amanda (Marlee Maitlin), a wedding photographer who's bummed because her slimy husband cheated on her. HCI president Peter Vegso stated that in regard to this book, "What the Bleep is the quantum leap in the New Age world," and "by marrying science and spirituality, it is the foundation of future thought."[5]. While the movie "What The Bleep" has some flaws from a science point of view, science of this type is so foreign to most people, that they feel they have to "jazz it up" to keep people interested. The bits and pieces of matter that make up sub-atomic particles (protons, neutrons and electrons) don't exist in any handy, measurable way unless they're interacting with one another. Some ideas discussed in the film are: In the narrative segments of the film, Marlee Matlin portrays Amanda, a photographer who plays the role of everywoman as she experiences her life from startlingly new and different perspectives.